Skip to main content
skill CX Codex

ccf-paper-reviewer — Claude Code skill: what it does, how to install

The ccf-paper-reviewer skill for Claude Code reviews scientific manuscripts, helping assess claims, evidence, and writing quality before submission.

MIT 2,300 installs ★ 3,769 updated 2026-10-20

Install into Claude Code · Skills CLI (Vercel) All methods and platforms ↓
npx skills add mikubaka88/CCFA-Skills --skill ccf-paper-reviewer -a claude-code
Open on GitHub

What ccf-paper-reviewer does

The ccf-paper-reviewer skill performs a structured analysis of scientific papers, theses, or other manuscripts. It assesses the novelty, significance, and soundness of scientific claims, alongside paragraph logic, terminology, and material presentation. The ccf-humanization and ccf-common skills are required for its operation.

This skill does not rewrite text or generate new experiments. It operates in various modes: scientific for content evaluation, writing for prose quality, full for a comprehensive check, or version-comparison for comparing drafts. For concept-only judgments, ccf-idea-reviewer should be used, while ccf-paper-writer handles prose edits.

To address significant gaps, the skill can integrate with ccf-literature-searcher for related work, ccf-integrity-auditor for data verification, or ccf-experiment-designer for protocol interpretation. An independent_review option allows for an external expert assessment, prepared by the scripts/prepare_expert_review.py script using GPT-6.

What it helps with

  • Evaluate scientific novelty and significance of a manuscript
  • Verify claims and presented evidence
  • Improve prose logic and terminology
  • Compare two document versions and identify changes
  • Get a structured review of an article's quality

Example prompts for the agent

  • Review my_paper.pdf for scientific claims.
  • Perform a writing review of draft_v2.docx.
  • Compare paper_v1.tex and paper_v2.tex.

How to install ccf-paper-reviewer

1Skills CLI (Vercel)

npx skills add mikubaka88/CCFA-Skills --skill ccf-paper-reviewer -a claude-code

2Manually: put the files in place

~/.claude/skills/ccf-paper-reviewer/SKILL.md

Copy the whole skill folder; for one project use .claude/skills/ccf-paper-reviewer/

Step by step, with commands for each platform: How to install skills in Claude Code: five ways

Questions about ccf-paper-reviewer

How do I install ccf-paper-reviewer in Claude Code?

To install in Claude Code, use the command npx skills add mikubaka88/CCFA-Skills --skill ccf-paper-reviewer -a claude-code. Then activate the skill by specifying the path ~/.claude/skills/ccf-paper-reviewer/SKILL.md.

What does the ccf-paper-reviewer skill do?

It performs a structured analysis of scientific manuscripts, assessing their novelty, significance, claim validity, and writing quality. The skill helps prepare a paper for publication without rewriting it.

What are the prerequisites for ccf-paper-reviewer?

The ccf-humanization and ccf-common skills are required. The independent review option needs access to GPT-6.

Source text

SKILL.md · MIT
---
name: ccf-paper-reviewer
description: "Review manuscript claims, evidence, and writing without rewriting. Use for 文章审核, 审稿, 稿件有什么硬伤, 结论站得住吗, 投稿成熟度, writing review, and version comparison. Return a structured scientific or writing review; scores need not be explicitly requested. Concept-only judgment belongs to ccf-idea-reviewer even with a full PDF; requested prose edits belong to ccf-paper-writer."
metadata:
  ccf_skill_controls:
    handoff_question_mode: partial
    respect_session_denylists: true
    protect_idea_scope_in_writing: true
    private_material_safety: moderate
    shared_controls: ../ccf-common/references/
---

# CCF Paper Reviewer

## Preflight And Ownership

Apply [ccf-humanization](../ccf-humanization/SKILL.md) first, then [ccf-common](../ccf-common/SKILL.md); reuse applicable active rules at handoffs. Both remain required. Handoff mode is **PARTIAL**, governed by metadata and Common's [handoff rules](../ccf-common/references/handoff-modes.md).

Assess manuscript claims, support and writing without rewriting. A concept-only question belongs to `ccf-idea-reviewer`, even with a full PDF; requested prose edits belong to `ccf-paper-writer`, and responses/revision ledgers to `ccf-rebuttal-writer`. Do not invent citations, results, missing related work, consensus, score movement or acceptance probabilities. Keep private manuscripts and reviews within the authorized boundary; use public-safe transformed queries under [privacy-and-evidence.md](../ccf-common/references/privacy-and-evidence.md).

Before file work follow [artifact-contracts.md](../ccf-common/references/artifact-contracts.md): reuse canonical paths and one stable task directory, default `ccfa-workfiles/<purpose>/<artifact-id>/`, preserve inputs, update in place, and check UTF-8/Chinese text. A bounded internal check returns findings to its integrating owner without another full report.

## Review Modes And References

| Mode | Assessment and relevant guidance |
| --- | --- |
| `scientific` | Novelty, significance, soundness and the paper's actual evidence, appropriate to contribution type. Use [review-workflow.md](references/review-workflow.md), [universal-review-rubric.md](references/universal-review-rubric.md) and [reviewer-panel.md](references/reviewer-panel.md) as needed. |
| `writing` | Paragraph logic, section flow, terminology, contribution display, claim presentation, captions and LaTeX-facing risks. Use relevant [prose guardrails](../ccf-paper-writer/references/prose-quality-guardrails.md) and `references/writing-review/`; no scientific acceptance score or automatic new experiments. |
| `full` | Scientific plus writing/format checks and consolidated action priorities. |
| `version-comparison` | Read [version-comparison.md](references/version-comparison.md) before scoring. Freeze the comparison contract; keep relative progress and absolute readiness as separate scorecards, with confidence separate from both. |

For scores, panels, AC/meta-review, change conditions, or standard reports, load [review-output-standards.md](../ccf-common/references/review-output-standards.md). [calibration-and-rank.md](references/calibration-and-rank.md) is the sole generic seven-dimension rubric; use a verified venue form when applicable. [venue-review-styles.md](references/venue-review-styles.md) and [desk-checks.md](references/desk-checks.md) apply to consequential venue decisions. Verify current official year/track rules rather than treating legacy guides as final policy; ICLR 2027 review needs its ICLR guidance and AI-use distinction between author pre-review and official assignment. For CVPR 2027, use the exact-year guidance and Common's approved-tool boundary for assigned confidential reviews; an author's internal pre-submission review retains its ordinary scope.

Identify the draft phase. Internal alignment checks of content-first or results-pending drafts assess explanation and consistency, with absent empirical adequacy `not assessed`; no invented acceptance score, imposed page limit or experiment campaign. Unsupported empirical assertions remain findings. A requested full submission review still reports real evidence incompleteness under its normal rubric. [materials-to-manuscript.md](../ccf-paper-writer/references/materials-to-manuscript.md) defines the draft contract.

## Evidence And Findings

Read the supplied scientific work and relevant dependencies at the requested coverage; filenames and excerpts do not establish whole-paper inspection. Reconstruct contributions, claims and support before judgment. Anchor concerns to actual locations. For every major/critical concern, inspect the strongest supplied passage or appendix that could answer it; record the countercheck and withdraw or narrow refuted criticism. Separate confirmed flaw, unsupported claim, clarification and missing input. Do not force praise, disagreement, or a concern quota.

Resolve consequential gaps through `ccf-literature-searcher` for closest work/benchmarks, `ccf-integrity-auditor` for numerical/citation-support conflicts, or `ccf-experiment-designer` for protocol interpretation. Reuse checks and respect no-browsing/supplied-evidence limits. Review does not authorize manuscript edits or new experiments. A low score needs its deduction and repair condition; confidence and inspected coverage are distinct from quality.

## Optional Independent Expert

[plain-expert-review.md](references/plain-expert-review.md) implements the existing `independent_review` switch as one fresh-context GPT-6 specialist reading, not an extra layer. `off` adds none automatically; `auto` requires a consequential unresolved judgment or useful requested pre-submission check; `on` favors a relevant substantial scientific/full pass when valuable. Explicit requests override the switch for this task without saving changes. Writing-only does not automatically invoke scientific expertise; concept-only stays with the idea owner.

`scripts/prepare_expert_review.py` prepares a source-bound neutral request, never a model call. Pass scope/question, exclusions, material locations and actual execution identity; withhold main-review conclusions, scores, generation history and other candidates. Preserve user model/effort choices and mandatory preflights. Missing GPT-6 or genuine fresh-context support limits only this extra pass. Record actual model, settings and inspected coverage; never claim a human or official reviewer. Verify returned evidence, merge duplicate concerns under stable IDs, and integrate once without votes, repeated full reviews or indefinite debate. Reuse requires matching inputs, guidance, actual runtime/options and coverage.

## Report Contract

For a user-requested report read [fixed-output-format.md](references/fixed-output-format.md): detailed by default, fourteen sections for scientific/full, nine for writing, five only for explicit brief/restrictive output. Narrow scope, a short prompt, or no-score request does not select brief output or broaden the assessment. Honor an explicit venue/user schema. Use the template's typed findings, stable concern IDs and bracketed references; keep one canonical explanation and scorecard rather than a report per role. Preserve historical dimensions/weights for relative comparisons and assess current readiness separately.

For standard scientific/full review with local paper and authorized file output, reuse the established report or the canonical Markdown file in `ccfa-review-reports/`; otherwise return it in context. Follow [review-workflow.md](references/review-workflow.md) for filename/location rules; no dated report per rerun. Validate saved default-format reports with `scripts/validate_version_comparison.py --report`; structural validation does not prove scientific correctness.

Internal contributions return inspected scope, located findings, resolved/open concern IDs and completion conditions, without inheriting a full report or panel. For a [writing context packet](../ccf-paper-writer/references/writing-execution.md), inspect necessary dependencies and preserve declared excerpt/section coverage. Return findings without applying manuscript patches; the writer owns authorized integration.

© mikubaka88 · MIT · mikubaka88/CCFA-Skills

Similar skills

All skills for Science and research →
academic-paper-review bytedance academic-paper-review — a skill for automated peer review of academic papers following top-conference standards. Assesses methodology, evaluates novelty, identifies weaknesses, and delivers evidence-based critique. CX Codex +1 2,800installs academic-paper-reviewer Imbad0202 The academic-paper-reviewer skill reviews an academic paper through five role-based perspectives. Use it for peer review, revision checks, or a focused methodology assessment. CX Codex +1 10,600installs scientific-writing K-Dense-AI The scientific-writing skill drafts and audits scientific manuscripts and reports while tying claims to verified evidence. Use it for sections, references, declarations, and submission checks. CX Codex +1 2,700installs nature-writing Community contribution based on curated Nature/Nature Communications writing patterns and open research-writing notes The nature-writing skill drafts and restructures Nature-style research writing from claims, results, figures, notes, or Chinese drafts. Use it for a section, outline, or full manuscript argument. CX Codex +1 306installs nature-story franklee16 nature-story — a skill that transforms raw research ideas into rigorous scientific narratives with competing hypotheses, literature benchmarks, and figure-driven paper plans. CX Codex +1 ★ 240repo stars paper-self-review Galaxy-Dawn paper-self-review is a Claude Code skill that checks academic paper structure, reasoning, and whether evidence supports its claims. It runs for self-review before a journal or conference submission. CX Codex +1 702installs

From the same set18

The whole set →
ccf-experiment-designer ccf-experiment-designer — a Claude Code skill for designing scientific experiments and interpreting results. Runs during benchmark planning and ablation studies. CX Codex +1 2,300installs ccf-literature-searcher ccf-literature-searcher — a Claude Code skill that finds and checks research papers, datasets, and benchmarks. It runs for literature reviews, prior-art checks, and research opportunity mapping. CX Codex +1 2,300installs ccf-idea-optimizer ccf-idea-optimizer — a Claude Code skill that turns rough research ideas into a question, a problem analysis, and a proposed research plan. It activates for direction finding or mechanism development. CX Codex +1 2,300installs ccf-paper-writer ccf-paper-writer — a skill for Claude Code drafts, edits, compresses, and adapts academic papers for CCF venues. It handles complete section drafts, trims excess length, and prepares text for slides. CX Codex +1 2,300installs ccf-humanization ccf-humanization runs before every other CCFA skill and strips empty defensive framing from reasoning and prose while leaving evidence, caveats and numbers intact. CX Codex +1 2,300installs ccf-common ccf-common sets baseline preflight checks, routing, and artifact contracts for CCFA skills. Runs right after ccf-humanization before handing tasks to research specialists. CX Codex +1 2,300installs ccf-submission-checker ccf-submission-checker — a Claude Code skill checks CCF venue requirements and submission-package readiness. Run it to review formatting, a TeX/PDF build, or artifact reproducibility. CX Codex +1 2,200installs ccf-rebuttal-writer ccf-rebuttal-writer — a skill for automating review rebuttals and revision tracking in academic submissions. It generates response letters, resubmission plans, and revision ledgers while adhering to formatting standards. CX Codex +1 2,200installs

Project sponsors

Companies that keep this analytics open