Skip to main content
command CX Codex

decision-quality-analyzer · davepoon — Claude Code command: what it does, install

decision-quality-analyzer scores how a team reaches a decision: four quality axes, a bias sweep, and scenario runs on past and hypothetical calls.

MIT ★ 3,785 updated 2026-10-25

Install into Claude Code · Plugin marketplace All methods and platforms ↓
/plugin marketplace add davepoon/buildwithclaude
/plugin install all-commands@buildwithclaude
Open on GitHub

What decision-quality-analyzer does

The command takes a decision apart in stages. First it pins down the setting: what kind of call this is, how the team usually makes such calls, who is affected, which numbers count as success. Then it rates the call on four axes worth 25% each: process, outcome, timing, and how much the team learns from it.

A second pass hunts biases. Personal ones such as anchoring or sticking with a failed path because of money already spent. Group ones, groupthink and deference to whoever is senior. Organizational ones, a preference for the status quo or judging only by the winners. Each comes with a countermeasure: a designated critic, a red team review, a pre-mortem, forecasting from comparable cases.

Scenario work closes it out. The team replays its process on decisions already made, runs stress cases with a deadline and gaps in the data, picks apart near-misses. Pass your criteria as the argument. Without them the command opens with questions about the decision type and the current process, so you get questions before analysis. Terminal access is limited to Bash(gh *).

What it helps with

  • Find the weak step in a decision process: data gathering, alternatives, or timing
  • Catch biases in a call everyone already agrees on
  • Stress-test a plan against deadline pressure and thin information
  • Turn an old decision into a written lesson
  • Make devil's advocate and pre-mortem a standing habit

Example prompts for the agent

  • /decision-quality-analyzer review our database choice, criteria: support cost, migration risk, hiring pool
  • Run our vendor decision through the bias framework and tell me which countermeasures we skipped
  • Replay last quarter's pricing change as a historical scenario and show where the process broke

How to install decision-quality-analyzer

1Plugin marketplace

/plugin marketplace add davepoon/buildwithclaude
/plugin install all-commands@buildwithclaude

2Manually: put the files in place

.claude/commands/decision-quality-analyzer.md

Call it with /decision-quality-analyzer. For all projects use ~/.claude/commands/

Questions about decision-quality-analyzer

How to install decision-quality-analyzer in Claude Code?

Add the marketplace with /plugin marketplace add davepoon/buildwithclaude, then run /plugin install all-commands@buildwithclaude.

What does decision-quality-analyzer do?

It rates a decision on process, outcome, timing and learning, lists likely biases alongside countermeasures, and tests the process on scenarios.

What do I pass to the command?

Your analysis criteria as the argument. With none, it asks about the decision type and how the team decides today.

Source text

decision-quality-analyzer.md · MIT
---
description: Analyze decision quality with scenario testing, bias detection, and team decision-making process optimization.
category: team-collaboration
argument-hint: "Specify analysis criteria"
allowed-tools: Bash(gh *)
---

# Decision Quality Analyzer

Analyze decision quality with scenario testing, bias detection, and team decision-making process optimization.

## Instructions

You are tasked with systematically analyzing and improving team decision quality through scenario analysis, bias detection, and process optimization. Follow this approach: **$ARGUMENTS**

### 1. Decision Context Assessment

**Critical Decision Quality Context:**

- **Decision Type**: What category of decision are you analyzing?
- **Decision Process**: How does the team currently make this type of decision?
- **Stakeholders**: Who participates in and is affected by these decisions?
- **Success Metrics**: How do you measure decision quality and outcomes?
- **Historical Data**: What past decisions provide learning opportunities?

**If context is unclear, guide systematically:**

```
Missing Decision Type:
"What type of team decision needs quality analysis?
- Strategic Decisions: Product direction, market positioning, technology choices
- Operational Decisions: Process improvements, resource allocation, priority setting
- Personnel Decisions: Hiring, team structure, role assignments, performance management
- Technical Decisions: Architecture choices, tool selection, implementation approaches

Please specify the decision scope and typical complexity level."

Missing Decision Process:
"How does your team currently make these decisions?
- Individual Authority: Single decision maker with consultation
- Consensus Building: Group discussion until agreement is reached
- Majority Vote: Democratic process with formal or informal voting
- Delegated Authority: Decision rights assigned to specific roles or committees
- Data-Driven: Systematic analysis and evidence-based approaches"
```

### 2. Decision Quality Framework

**Systematic decision evaluation methodology:**

#### Quality Dimension Assessment
```
Multi-Dimensional Decision Quality:

Process Quality (25% weight):
- Information Gathering: Completeness and accuracy of data collection
- Stakeholder Involvement: Appropriate participation and perspective inclusion
- Alternative Generation: Creativity and comprehensiveness of option development
- Analysis Rigor: Systematic evaluation and trade-off assessment

Outcome Quality (25% weight):
- Goal Achievement: Success in reaching intended objectives
- Unintended Consequences: Management of secondary effects and side impacts
- Stakeholder Satisfaction: Acceptance and support from affected parties
- Long-term Sustainability: Durability and adaptability of decision outcomes

Timing Quality (25% weight):
- Decision Speed: Appropriate pace for urgency and complexity
- Information Timing: Optimal balance of speed vs additional information
- Implementation Timing: Coordination with market conditions and organizational readiness
- Review Timing: Appropriate schedule for decision assessment and adjustment

Learning Quality (25% weight):
- Knowledge Capture: Documentation and institutional learning
- Bias Recognition: Awareness and mitigation of cognitive biases
- Process Improvement: Methodology enhancement based on outcomes
- Capability Building: Team decision-making skill development
```

#### Decision Success Metrics
- Quantitative outcomes (financial, operational, performance metrics)
- Qualitative outcomes (satisfaction, engagement, strategic alignment)
- Process efficiency (time to decision, resource utilization)
- Learning outcomes (knowledge gained, capability developed)

### 3. Bias Detection and Mitigation

**Systematic cognitive bias identification:**

#### Common Decision Biases
```
Team Decision Bias Framework:

Individual Cognitive Biases:
- Confirmation Bias: Seeking information that supports preconceptions
- Anchoring Bias: Over-relying on first information received
- Availability Bias: Overweighting easily recalled examples
- Overconfidence Bias: Excessive certainty in judgment accuracy
- Sunk Cost Fallacy: Continuing failed approaches due to past investment

Group Decision Biases:
- Groupthink: Pressure for harmony reducing critical evaluation
- Risky Shift: Groups making riskier decisions than individuals
- Authority Bias: Deferring to hierarchy rather than evidence
- Social Proof: Following others' decisions without independent analysis
- Planning Fallacy: Systematic underestimation of time and resources

Organizational Biases:
- Status Quo Bias: Preferring current state over change
- Not Invented Here: Rejecting external ideas and solutions
- Survivorship Bias: Focusing only on successful cases
- Attribution Bias: Misattributing success and failure causes
- Political Bias: Decisions influenced by organizational politics
```

#### Bias Mitigation Strategies
```
Systematic Bias Reduction:

Process-Based Mitigation:
- Devil's Advocate: Designated critical evaluation role
- Red Team Analysis: Systematic challenge of assumptions and conclusions
- Diverse Perspectives: Multi-functional and multi-level input
- Anonymous Input: Reducing social pressure and hierarchy effects

Tool-Based Mitigation:
- Decision Trees: Systematic option evaluation and comparison
- Pre-mortem Analysis: Imagining failure scenarios and prevention
- Reference Class Forecasting: Using similar historical examples
- Outside View: External perspective and benchmarking

Cultural Mitigation:
- Psychological Safety: Encouraging dissent and critical thinking
- Learning Orientation: Celebrating learning from failures
- Evidence-Based Culture: Valuing data over intuition and politics
- Continuous Improvement: Regular process assessment and enhancement
```

### 4. Scenario-Based Decision Testing

**Test decision quality through hypothetical scenarios:**

#### Decision Scenario Framework
```
Comprehensive Decision Testing:

Historical Scenario Testing:
- Apply current decision process to past decisions
- Compare predicted vs actual outcomes
- Identify process improvements that would have helped
- Calibrate decision confidence and accuracy

Hypothetical Scenario Testing:
- Create realistic decision scenarios for practice
- Test team process under different conditions
- Identify process strengths and weaknesses
- Build team decision-making capability

Stress Test Scenarios:
- Time pressure and urgency constraints
- Incomplete information and high uncertainty
- Conflicting stakeholder interests and priorities
- High-stakes decisions with significant consequences

Learning Scenarios:
- Successful decision analysis and pattern recognition
- Failed decision post-mortem and lesson extraction
- Near-miss analysis and improvement identification
- Best practice sharing and capability transfer
```

#### Simulation-Based Improvement
- Role-playing exercises for complex decision scenarios
- Process experimentation with low-stakes decisions
- A/B testing of different decision methodologies
- Scenario planning for future decision situations

### 5. Team Decision Process Optimization

**Systematic improvement of decision-making workflows:**

#### Process Enhancement Framework
```
Decision Process Optimization:

Information Management:
- Data Collection: Systematic gathering of relevant information
- Information Quality: Accuracy, completeness, and timeliness assessment
- Bias Detection: Recognition of information source biases
- Knowledge Synthesis: Integration of diverse information sources

Stakeholder Engagement:
- Identification: Complete mapping of affected and influential parties
- Consultation: Systematic input gathering and perspective integration
- Communication: Clear explanation of process and decision rationale
- Buy-in: Building support and commitment for implementation

Analysis and Evaluation:
- Option Generation: Creative and comprehensive alternative development
- Criteria Definition: Clear success metrics and evaluation standards
- Trade-off Analysis: Systematic comparison of costs and benefits
- Risk Assessment: Identification and mitigation of potential problems

Decision Implementation:
- Planning: Detailed implementation strategy and timeline
- Resource Allocation: Appropriate staffing and budget assignment
- Monitoring: Progress tracking and outcome measurement
- Adaptation: Course correction based on results and learning
```

#### Team Capability Building
- Decision-making skill training and development
- Process facilitation and meeting effectiveness
- Critical thinking and analytical capability enhancement
- Communication and stakeholder management improvement

### 6. Output Generation and Recommendations

**Present decision quality insights in actionable format:**

```
## Decision Quality Analysis: [Decision Type/Process]

### Current State Assessment
- Decision Process Maturity: [evaluation of current methodology]
- Quality Dimension Scores: [process, outcome, timing, learning ratings]
- Bias Vulnerability: [key cognitive biases affecting decisions]
- Stakeholder Satisfaction: [feedback on decision process and outcomes]

### Key Findings

#### Decision Process Strengths:
- Effective Practices: [what works well in current process]
- Quality Outcomes: [successful decisions and positive patterns]
- Team Capabilities: [strong skills and effective behaviors]
- Stakeholder Engagement: [successful involvement and communication]

#### Improvement Opportunities:
- Process Gaps: [missing steps or inadequate methodology]
- Bias Vulnerabilities: [cognitive biases affecting decision quality]
- Information Deficits: [data gaps and analysis weaknesses]
- Implementation Challenges: [execution and follow-through issues]

### Optimization Recommendations

#### Immediate Improvements (0-30 days):
- Process Quick Fixes: [simple methodology enhancements]
- Bias Mitigation: [specific techniques for bias reduction]
- Tool Implementation: [decision aids and analytical frameworks]
- Communication Enhancement: [stakeholder engagement improvements]

#### Medium-term Development (1-6 months):
- Capability Building: [training and skill development programs]
- Process Standardization: [consistent methodology across decisions]
- Quality Measurement: [metrics and feedback systems]
- Cultural Development: [decision-making mindset and values]

#### Long-term Transformation (6+ months):
- Organizational Learning: [institutional knowledge and capability]
- Advanced Analytics: [data-driven decision support systems]
- Innovation Integration: [new methodologies and tools]
- Competitive Advantage: [decision-making as strategic capability]

### Success Metrics and Monitoring
- Decision Quality KPIs: [measurable indicators of improvement]
- Process Efficiency Metrics: [speed and resource utilization]
- Outcome Tracking: [business results and stakeholder satisfaction]
- Learning Indicators: [capability development and knowledge capture]

### Implementation Roadmap
- Phase 1: [immediate process improvements and bias mitigation]
- Phase 2: [capability building and measurement system]
- Phase 3: [advanced methodology and cultural transformation]
- Success Criteria: [specific goals and achievement measures]
```

### 7. Continuous Learning Integration

**Establish ongoing decision quality improvement:**

#### Decision Outcome Tracking
- Systematic monitoring of decision results and impacts
- Correlation analysis between process quality and outcomes
- Pattern recognition for successful vs unsuccessful decisions
- Feedback integration for process refinement and enhancement

#### Organizational Learning
- Best practice identification and knowledge sharing
- Decision case study development and team learning
- Cross-functional learning and capability transfer
- Industry benchmark comparison and competitive analysis

## Usage Examples

```bash
# Product strategy decision analysis
/team:decision-quality-analyzer Analyze product roadmap prioritization decisions for bias and process improvement opportunities

# Technical architecture decision assessment
/team:decision-quality-analyzer Evaluate technology stack decisions using scenario testing and stakeholder satisfaction analysis

# Hiring process decision optimization
/team:decision-quality-analyzer Optimize candidate evaluation and selection process through bias detection and outcome tracking

# Investment decision quality improvement
/team:decision-quality-analyzer Improve capital allocation decisions through process standardization and learning integration
```

## Quality Indicators

- **Green**: Comprehensive bias analysis, validated process improvements, outcome tracking
- **Yellow**: Basic bias recognition, some process enhancement, limited outcome measurement
- **Red**: Minimal bias awareness, ad-hoc process, no systematic improvement

## Common Pitfalls to Avoid

- Analysis paralysis: Over-analyzing decisions instead of improving decision-making
- Bias blindness: Not recognizing team and organizational cognitive biases
- Process rigidity: Creating inflexible procedures that slow appropriate decisions
- Outcome fixation: Judging process quality only by outcomes rather than methodology
- Individual focus: Ignoring group dynamics and organizational factors
- One-size-fits-all: Using same process for all decision types and contexts

Transform team decision-making from intuition-based guessing into systematic, evidence-driven capability that creates sustainable competitive advantage.

© BuildWithClaude Community · MIT · davepoon/buildwithclaude

Similar slash commands

All slash commands for Notes, tasks and projects →

decision-quality-analyzer by other authors comes first.

decision-quality-analyzer davila7 decision-quality-analyzer evaluates team decision making, flags cognitive biases, and stress-tests project scenarios directly from Git history. CX Codex +1 258installs decision-memo gasserane decision-memo turns a pending choice into a written memo: context, options, a recommendation, risks and reversibility. Useful when a decision needs a record. CX Codex +1 688installs decision-debate gasserane decision-debate runs a structured debate between autonomous specialist agents on tough MEL and SRHR design choices. It helps review clashing perspectives before committing to a plan. CX Codex +1 383installs decision-toolkit glebis The decision-toolkit skill builds interactive tools for hard choices: step-by-step wizards, bias checklists, scenario explorers and dashboards. CX Codex +1 325installs decision-navigator qdhenry decision-navigator structures complex choices, scores trade-offs, and quantifies risk factors. Useful when you need to assess the reversibility and consequences of technical plans. CX Codex ★ 1,357repo stars architecture-decision-record OrchestKit Creates structured Architecture Decision Records with context, decisions, consequences, and alternatives. It supports documenting choices and tracking their status. CX Codex +1 1,500installs decision-matrix lyndonkl decision-matrix compares alternatives against weighted criteria, calculates scores, checks sensitivity to weight changes, and delivers a recommendation with trade-off analysis. CX Codex +1 165installs

From the same set235

The whole set →
gsd:reapply-patches gsd:reapply-patches is a Claude Code skill that carries local GSD changes into the installed version after an update. It handles updates that replaced customized files. CX Codex +1 ★ 3,785repo stars twitter-algorithm-optimizer twitter-algorithm-optimizer — a skill for Claude Code and Cursor that rewrites tweets to match X ranking algorithms so your post reaches more followers and non-followers. CX Codex +1 ★ 3,785repo stars gitlab-automation gitlab-automation automates GitLab project tasks, issue tracking, merge requests, branch operations, and CI/CD pipelines through Rube MCP. CX Codex +1 ★ 3,785repo stars future-scenario-generator future-scenario-generator builds future scenarios from trends and scores how plausible they are. Use it to compare possible outcomes before making a decision. CX Codex +1 ★ 3,785repo stars hypotheses-manager hypotheses-manager evaluates startup hypotheses against interview evidence using backlinks and returns the smallest next validation move. Runs via the main agent. CX Codex ★ 3,785repo stars gsd-integration-checker The gsd-integration-checker subagent traces connections between project phases and follows user journeys through the code. Use it to spot broken wiring that a component-by-component review can miss. CX Codex ★ 3,785repo stars gsd-ui-researcher gsd-ui-researcher — a subagent that reads requirements and project context, detects design system state, and produces UI-SPEC.md—a design contract document for frontend phases. Invoked by the /gsd:ui-phase orchestrator. CX Codex ★ 3,785repo stars simulation-calibrator simulation-calibrator calibrates simulation accuracy through back-testing and structured validation loops. Useful when tuning business, behavioral, or technical system models. CX Codex +1 ★ 3,785repo stars

Project sponsors

Companies that keep this analytics open