decision-quality-analyzer · davepoon — команда для Claude Code
Команда decision-quality-analyzer разбирает, как команда принимает решения: оценивает процесс по четырём измерениям, ищет искажения и прогоняет решение на сценариях.
MIT ★ 3 785 обновлён 2026-10-25
/plugin marketplace add davepoon/buildwithclaude
/plugin install all-commands@buildwithclaudeЧто делает decision-quality-analyzer
Команда ведёт разбор решения по шагам. Сначала фиксирует контекст: тип решения, как команда принимает такие решения сейчас, кто участвует и кого это задевает, по каким метрикам считается успех. Дальше идёт оценка по четырём измерениям с весом 25% каждое: качество процесса, результата, сроков и обучения.
Отдельный блок — искажения. Перебираются личные (якорение, подтверждение своей правоты, потерянные вложения), групповые (групповое мышление, почтение к должности) и организационные (страх перемен, опора только на удачные примеры). К каждому предлагаются контрмеры: адвокат дьявола, red team, pre-mortem, прогноз по похожим случаям.
Сценарии — третья часть: прогон текущего процесса на прошлых решениях, стресс-кейсы с дедлайном и неполными данными, разбор промахов. Критерии анализа задаются аргументом; если их нет, команда начнёт с вопросов о типе решения и текущем процессе, а не с разбора. Из терминала ей разрешён только Bash(gh *).
Какие задачи решает
- Найти слабое место в процессе: сбор данных, набор альтернатив или сроки
- Поймать искажения в решении, с которым команда уже согласна
- Прогнать план на стресс-сценарии с дедлайном и неполными данными
- Разобрать прошлое решение и вытащить из него урок
- Завести адвоката дьявола и pre-mortem как регулярную практику
Примеры запросов агенту
- /decision-quality-analyzer разбери выбор стека для нового сервиса, критерии: сроки, стоимость поддержки, риски
- Проверь решение о найме тимлида на искажения и покажи, какие контрмеры мы пропустили
- Прогони прошлогодний отказ от подписки как исторический сценарий и скажи, где процесс дал сбой
Как установить decision-quality-analyzer
1Через маркетплейс плагинов
/plugin marketplace add davepoon/buildwithclaude/plugin install all-commands@buildwithclaude2Вручную: положить файлы
.claude/commands/decision-quality-analyzer.mdВызов — /decision-quality-analyzer. Для всех проектов — ~/.claude/commands/
Вручную: положить файлы
~/.codex/prompts/decision-quality-analyzer.mdВызов — /prompts:decision-quality-analyzer. В Codex этот формат помечен устаревшим, замена — скиллы
Вручную: положить файлы
.github/prompts/decision-quality-analyzer.prompt.mdВручную: положить файлы
.gemini/commands/decision-quality-analyzer.tomlGemini хранит команды в TOML: текст запроса — в поле prompt
Вопросы о decision-quality-analyzer
Как установить decision-quality-analyzer в Claude Code?
Сначала добавьте маркетплейс: /plugin marketplace add davepoon/buildwithclaude. Затем поставьте плагин с командой: /plugin install all-commands@buildwithclaude.
Что делает decision-quality-analyzer?
Оценивает решение по четырём измерениям — процесс, результат, сроки, обучение, — перечисляет вероятные искажения с контрмерами и проверяет процесс на сценариях.
Что передать команде при вызове?
Критерии анализа через аргумент. Без них команда сначала спросит тип решения и то, как команда принимает такие решения сейчас.
Исходный текст
decision-quality-analyzer.md · MIT
--- description: Analyze decision quality with scenario testing, bias detection, and team decision-making process optimization. category: team-collaboration argument-hint: "Specify analysis criteria" allowed-tools: Bash(gh *) --- # Decision Quality Analyzer Analyze decision quality with scenario testing, bias detection, and team decision-making process optimization. ## Instructions You are tasked with systematically analyzing and improving team decision quality through scenario analysis, bias detection, and process optimization. Follow this approach: **$ARGUMENTS** ### 1. Decision Context Assessment **Critical Decision Quality Context:** - **Decision Type**: What category of decision are you analyzing? - **Decision Process**: How does the team currently make this type of decision? - **Stakeholders**: Who participates in and is affected by these decisions? - **Success Metrics**: How do you measure decision quality and outcomes? - **Historical Data**: What past decisions provide learning opportunities? **If context is unclear, guide systematically:** ``` Missing Decision Type: "What type of team decision needs quality analysis? - Strategic Decisions: Product direction, market positioning, technology choices - Operational Decisions: Process improvements, resource allocation, priority setting - Personnel Decisions: Hiring, team structure, role assignments, performance management - Technical Decisions: Architecture choices, tool selection, implementation approaches Please specify the decision scope and typical complexity level." Missing Decision Process: "How does your team currently make these decisions? - Individual Authority: Single decision maker with consultation - Consensus Building: Group discussion until agreement is reached - Majority Vote: Democratic process with formal or informal voting - Delegated Authority: Decision rights assigned to specific roles or committees - Data-Driven: Systematic analysis and evidence-based approaches" ``` ### 2. Decision Quality Framework **Systematic decision evaluation methodology:** #### Quality Dimension Assessment ``` Multi-Dimensional Decision Quality: Process Quality (25% weight): - Information Gathering: Completeness and accuracy of data collection - Stakeholder Involvement: Appropriate participation and perspective inclusion - Alternative Generation: Creativity and comprehensiveness of option development - Analysis Rigor: Systematic evaluation and trade-off assessment Outcome Quality (25% weight): - Goal Achievement: Success in reaching intended objectives - Unintended Consequences: Management of secondary effects and side impacts - Stakeholder Satisfaction: Acceptance and support from affected parties - Long-term Sustainability: Durability and adaptability of decision outcomes Timing Quality (25% weight): - Decision Speed: Appropriate pace for urgency and complexity - Information Timing: Optimal balance of speed vs additional information - Implementation Timing: Coordination with market conditions and organizational readiness - Review Timing: Appropriate schedule for decision assessment and adjustment Learning Quality (25% weight): - Knowledge Capture: Documentation and institutional learning - Bias Recognition: Awareness and mitigation of cognitive biases - Process Improvement: Methodology enhancement based on outcomes - Capability Building: Team decision-making skill development ``` #### Decision Success Metrics - Quantitative outcomes (financial, operational, performance metrics) - Qualitative outcomes (satisfaction, engagement, strategic alignment) - Process efficiency (time to decision, resource utilization) - Learning outcomes (knowledge gained, capability developed) ### 3. Bias Detection and Mitigation **Systematic cognitive bias identification:** #### Common Decision Biases ``` Team Decision Bias Framework: Individual Cognitive Biases: - Confirmation Bias: Seeking information that supports preconceptions - Anchoring Bias: Over-relying on first information received - Availability Bias: Overweighting easily recalled examples - Overconfidence Bias: Excessive certainty in judgment accuracy - Sunk Cost Fallacy: Continuing failed approaches due to past investment Group Decision Biases: - Groupthink: Pressure for harmony reducing critical evaluation - Risky Shift: Groups making riskier decisions than individuals - Authority Bias: Deferring to hierarchy rather than evidence - Social Proof: Following others' decisions without independent analysis - Planning Fallacy: Systematic underestimation of time and resources Organizational Biases: - Status Quo Bias: Preferring current state over change - Not Invented Here: Rejecting external ideas and solutions - Survivorship Bias: Focusing only on successful cases - Attribution Bias: Misattributing success and failure causes - Political Bias: Decisions influenced by organizational politics ``` #### Bias Mitigation Strategies ``` Systematic Bias Reduction: Process-Based Mitigation: - Devil's Advocate: Designated critical evaluation role - Red Team Analysis: Systematic challenge of assumptions and conclusions - Diverse Perspectives: Multi-functional and multi-level input - Anonymous Input: Reducing social pressure and hierarchy effects Tool-Based Mitigation: - Decision Trees: Systematic option evaluation and comparison - Pre-mortem Analysis: Imagining failure scenarios and prevention - Reference Class Forecasting: Using similar historical examples - Outside View: External perspective and benchmarking Cultural Mitigation: - Psychological Safety: Encouraging dissent and critical thinking - Learning Orientation: Celebrating learning from failures - Evidence-Based Culture: Valuing data over intuition and politics - Continuous Improvement: Regular process assessment and enhancement ``` ### 4. Scenario-Based Decision Testing **Test decision quality through hypothetical scenarios:** #### Decision Scenario Framework ``` Comprehensive Decision Testing: Historical Scenario Testing: - Apply current decision process to past decisions - Compare predicted vs actual outcomes - Identify process improvements that would have helped - Calibrate decision confidence and accuracy Hypothetical Scenario Testing: - Create realistic decision scenarios for practice - Test team process under different conditions - Identify process strengths and weaknesses - Build team decision-making capability Stress Test Scenarios: - Time pressure and urgency constraints - Incomplete information and high uncertainty - Conflicting stakeholder interests and priorities - High-stakes decisions with significant consequences Learning Scenarios: - Successful decision analysis and pattern recognition - Failed decision post-mortem and lesson extraction - Near-miss analysis and improvement identification - Best practice sharing and capability transfer ``` #### Simulation-Based Improvement - Role-playing exercises for complex decision scenarios - Process experimentation with low-stakes decisions - A/B testing of different decision methodologies - Scenario planning for future decision situations ### 5. Team Decision Process Optimization **Systematic improvement of decision-making workflows:** #### Process Enhancement Framework ``` Decision Process Optimization: Information Management: - Data Collection: Systematic gathering of relevant information - Information Quality: Accuracy, completeness, and timeliness assessment - Bias Detection: Recognition of information source biases - Knowledge Synthesis: Integration of diverse information sources Stakeholder Engagement: - Identification: Complete mapping of affected and influential parties - Consultation: Systematic input gathering and perspective integration - Communication: Clear explanation of process and decision rationale - Buy-in: Building support and commitment for implementation Analysis and Evaluation: - Option Generation: Creative and comprehensive alternative development - Criteria Definition: Clear success metrics and evaluation standards - Trade-off Analysis: Systematic comparison of costs and benefits - Risk Assessment: Identification and mitigation of potential problems Decision Implementation: - Planning: Detailed implementation strategy and timeline - Resource Allocation: Appropriate staffing and budget assignment - Monitoring: Progress tracking and outcome measurement - Adaptation: Course correction based on results and learning ``` #### Team Capability Building - Decision-making skill training and development - Process facilitation and meeting effectiveness - Critical thinking and analytical capability enhancement - Communication and stakeholder management improvement ### 6. Output Generation and Recommendations **Present decision quality insights in actionable format:** ``` ## Decision Quality Analysis: [Decision Type/Process] ### Current State Assessment - Decision Process Maturity: [evaluation of current methodology] - Quality Dimension Scores: [process, outcome, timing, learning ratings] - Bias Vulnerability: [key cognitive biases affecting decisions] - Stakeholder Satisfaction: [feedback on decision process and outcomes] ### Key Findings #### Decision Process Strengths: - Effective Practices: [what works well in current process] - Quality Outcomes: [successful decisions and positive patterns] - Team Capabilities: [strong skills and effective behaviors] - Stakeholder Engagement: [successful involvement and communication] #### Improvement Opportunities: - Process Gaps: [missing steps or inadequate methodology] - Bias Vulnerabilities: [cognitive biases affecting decision quality] - Information Deficits: [data gaps and analysis weaknesses] - Implementation Challenges: [execution and follow-through issues] ### Optimization Recommendations #### Immediate Improvements (0-30 days): - Process Quick Fixes: [simple methodology enhancements] - Bias Mitigation: [specific techniques for bias reduction] - Tool Implementation: [decision aids and analytical frameworks] - Communication Enhancement: [stakeholder engagement improvements] #### Medium-term Development (1-6 months): - Capability Building: [training and skill development programs] - Process Standardization: [consistent methodology across decisions] - Quality Measurement: [metrics and feedback systems] - Cultural Development: [decision-making mindset and values] #### Long-term Transformation (6+ months): - Organizational Learning: [institutional knowledge and capability] - Advanced Analytics: [data-driven decision support systems] - Innovation Integration: [new methodologies and tools] - Competitive Advantage: [decision-making as strategic capability] ### Success Metrics and Monitoring - Decision Quality KPIs: [measurable indicators of improvement] - Process Efficiency Metrics: [speed and resource utilization] - Outcome Tracking: [business results and stakeholder satisfaction] - Learning Indicators: [capability development and knowledge capture] ### Implementation Roadmap - Phase 1: [immediate process improvements and bias mitigation] - Phase 2: [capability building and measurement system] - Phase 3: [advanced methodology and cultural transformation] - Success Criteria: [specific goals and achievement measures] ``` ### 7. Continuous Learning Integration **Establish ongoing decision quality improvement:** #### Decision Outcome Tracking - Systematic monitoring of decision results and impacts - Correlation analysis between process quality and outcomes - Pattern recognition for successful vs unsuccessful decisions - Feedback integration for process refinement and enhancement #### Organizational Learning - Best practice identification and knowledge sharing - Decision case study development and team learning - Cross-functional learning and capability transfer - Industry benchmark comparison and competitive analysis ## Usage Examples ```bash # Product strategy decision analysis /team:decision-quality-analyzer Analyze product roadmap prioritization decisions for bias and process improvement opportunities # Technical architecture decision assessment /team:decision-quality-analyzer Evaluate technology stack decisions using scenario testing and stakeholder satisfaction analysis # Hiring process decision optimization /team:decision-quality-analyzer Optimize candidate evaluation and selection process through bias detection and outcome tracking # Investment decision quality improvement /team:decision-quality-analyzer Improve capital allocation decisions through process standardization and learning integration ``` ## Quality Indicators - **Green**: Comprehensive bias analysis, validated process improvements, outcome tracking - **Yellow**: Basic bias recognition, some process enhancement, limited outcome measurement - **Red**: Minimal bias awareness, ad-hoc process, no systematic improvement ## Common Pitfalls to Avoid - Analysis paralysis: Over-analyzing decisions instead of improving decision-making - Bias blindness: Not recognizing team and organizational cognitive biases - Process rigidity: Creating inflexible procedures that slow appropriate decisions - Outcome fixation: Judging process quality only by outcomes rather than methodology - Individual focus: Ignoring group dynamics and organizational factors - One-size-fits-all: Using same process for all decision types and contexts Transform team decision-making from intuition-based guessing into systematic, evidence-driven capability that creates sustainable competitive advantage.
© BuildWithClaude Community · MIT · davepoon/buildwithclaude
Похожие слэш-команды
Все слэш-команды по теме «Заметки, задачи и проекты» →Сначала — decision-quality-analyzer от других авторов.