chair — Claude Code prompt: review research proposals
The chair Claude Code prompt combines independent reviews of a research proposal into one meta-review. It checks overlap claims against supplied papers and picks an initial experiment.
no license ★ 159 updated 2026-11-02
.claude/commands/chair.mdWhat chair does
The prompt turns reviewer feedback into a JSON meta-review. It merges duplicate concerns, records which reviewers raised each issue, and orders them by severity. For overlap claims, it compares the reviewers’ statements with supplied reading notes and paper excerpts, cites page numbers, and labels judgments as paper-based or inferred.
The result also covers reviewer disagreements, questions for the author, and an experiment to test the idea first. That experiment includes a comparison, a metric, stop and continue criteria, and a duration in days. Supply the proposal, reviewers’ JSON meta-reviews, notes on related papers, and full-text excerpts of cited or overlapping papers. Work outside those materials is marked as unverifiable.
What it helps with
- combine repeated concerns from multiple reviewers
- check claims that a related paper already covers the proposal
- identify conflicting reviewer judgments
- choose an early experiment that could falsify the idea
Example prompts for the agent
- Combine these reviews into one meta-review and check the overlap claims against the attached papers.
- Compare the reviewers’ judgments, list their disagreements, and select an experiment to test the proposal first.
- Extract the main risks, questions for the author, and claims that need checking against the full texts.
How to install chair
Manually: put the files in place
.claude/commands/chair.mdHow to use
Paste the text at the start of a chat or into project instructions
Questions about chair
How do I install chair in Claude Code?
Place the command file at .claude/commands/chair.md.
What does chair do?
It combines reviews of a research proposal, checks overlap claims against supplied papers, and returns a JSON meta-review with a first experiment to run.
What does chair need to work?
Provide the proposal, reviewers’ JSON meta-reviews, notes on related papers, and full-text excerpts of cited or overlapping papers. Claims about work outside those materials cannot be verified.