A U.S. federal judge denied the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's emergency request to block New York from pursuing enforcement action against prediction market operator Kalshi. The ruling clears the way for a state court hearing on Monday, 23 November, where New York will seek to block Kalshi from operating in the state.
District Judge Lorna Schofield rejected the regulator's request on Friday, ruling that the CFTC failed to prove a likelihood of success in its argument that federal law bars states from applying gambling regulations to federally regulated prediction markets. A day earlier, another federal judge granted New York's motion to return its enforcement lawsuit against Kalshi to state court. Attorney General Letitia James is seeking a temporary restraining order to stop Kalshi from offering sports event contracts in New York.
CFTC warned of nationwide shutdown
In its 20 November emergency filing, the CFTC argued that blocking Kalshi in New York would effectively shut down the company's operations nationwide because its headquarters are located in the state. New York's request asks to prohibit Kalshi from operating 'within or from' New York. The CFTC called that language an 'existential threat' to the commission's registrants and regulatory jurisdiction.
Schofield denied the request, noting conflicting precedent: three appellate courts have ruled against Kalshi, one in favour. The dispute centres on whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling laws.
Hearing set for Monday
New York accuses Kalshi of unlicensed gambling activity in violation of state law. As in over 20 other states, Kalshi maintains its products are federally regulated derivatives under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction, which preempts state gambling laws.
The difference is that Kalshi's headquarters are in New York. The company warned that the restraining order language would prevent it from operating out of its New York office, affecting customers and trading across the U.S. Kalshi also pointed to a conflict: in August the CFTC ordered it to keep operating even if a court orders it to block New York, placing it between conflicting federal and state directives.
The attorney general's office responded on 20 November, accusing Kalshi of stalling enforcement while continuing to profit from New York customers. The state also noted that Kalshi allows users under 21 to wager on sports, including New York college teams, which violates state sports betting laws.