Attorneys general from 43 US states and the District of Columbia have demanded that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) withdraw a proposed rule classifying sports-related event contracts as swaps. The coalition argues the measure would undermine state gambling regulation and exceed the agency's statutory authority.
The bipartisan group filed its formal comment on November 18, the final day of public consultation. Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson led the effort alongside officials from Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah. The group insists that prediction-market contracts must remain outside CFTC jurisdiction and that states retain control over sports betting and consumer protection.
'A sports bet isn't a derivative just because the CFTC says so. The agency doesn't get to invent powers that Congress never gave it, ignore federal court decisions, and bulldoze state consumer protections,' Wilson said.
The CFTC published its proposed rulemaking on October 9, seeking to amend the definition of a swap under the Commodity Exchange Act to explicitly include contracts based on sports, political, cultural and weather-related events. The commission maintains these products are commodity derivatives within its regulatory remit. Chairman Michael Selig has defended the agency's authority, arguing the changes would clarify the treatment of event contracts under federal commodities law.
The attorneys general dispute that interpretation, citing appellate court decisions that reject the CFTC's claimed authority over sports betting. The coalition warns the rule would let prediction-market platforms bypass state licensing requirements, age restrictions and problem-gambling safeguards. Traditional sportsbooks could restructure as prediction markets to avoid state gambling laws, leaving consumers without established protections.
The coalition also questioned whether the CFTC has the required quorum to adopt the rule, given that only one commissioner currently serves. The attorneys general argue the CEA's vacancy provision does not authorise a single commissioner to exercise the commission's powers independently. A quorum requires at least two commissioners, possibly four. On November 12, President Donald Trump nominated Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland to the commission; both currently serve as legal advisers on the Senate Agriculture Committee.
The current push follows a July initiative when Ohio led 44 attorneys general in demanding the CFTC recognise state authority over sports-related prediction markets. Nevada's top gaming regulator has also criticised the commission's approach, while nine Democratic senators separately asked Selig to withdraw a November 5 interpretation on geofencing.