President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva banned Brazil's licensed betting sector in late September via Provisional Measure 1.394, freezing a market that had operated for nine months. The 85 licensed operators had paid BRL30 million ($6 million) each for five-year licences. In its first year, the regulated market generated nearly BRL10 billion in tax revenue.
Legal limbo and constitutional questions
The National Association of Games and Lotteries (ANJL) filed suit at Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF) immediately after the ban. The court held a public hearing in early November, then issued a stay order halting all lower-court proceedings pending its own ruling. Two prior injunctions had temporarily allowed operators to resume operations before being overturned.
Luiz Felipe Maia, founding partner of the law firm Maia Yoshiyasu Advogados, called the STF's stay order 'essentially unconstitutional'. Under the Brazilian Constitution, provisional measures apply only in important and urgent cases. Maia noted that the sole urgency appeared to be Lula's re-election campaign, which the announcement preceded by one week.
Black market gains ground
While licensed operators waited, illegal betting sites proliferated. On the day of the STF hearing, the ANJL identified 34,000 active illegal gambling websites. The industry shed over 3,500 jobs in the weeks following the ban, according to an ANJL survey in mid-October. Payment company Pay4Fun was among the firms forced to cut staff.
Congress likely to decide
Provisional measures lapse after 60 days unless converted into law, with an extension possible for another 60 days. This measure's validity has already been extended, and Congress must vote by 4 March, after its recess from 23 December through 1 February. Legal experts expect Congress, not the STF, to ultimately determine the sector's fate, given reputational risks the court faces from an unrelated corruption scandal.
If the market returns, only 5 to 10 of the original 85 licensed operators would likely survive five months of lost revenue, Maia predicted. Larger operators such as Betano, Bet365, Superbet, Blaze and Flutter might remain given Brazil's market scale, though foreign investor confidence in Brazilian regulation has suffered.