CFTC commissioner nominees Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick testified before the Senate Agriculture Committee on Tuesday, addressing prediction market regulation and staffing concerns at the commission. Neither candidate endorsed or rejected the CFTC's current approach to the sector. Both said they would consider stakeholder concerns. President Donald Trump nominated them last week. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig has served as the sole commissioner for nearly a year; the commission typically has five members, no more than three from the same party.
Rowland, a Democrat and committee staffer, said the Supreme Court will likely rule on prediction markets within the next term or the one after. If confirmed, he would be bound by that ruling. Anonick, a Republican and derivatives counsel to Senator John Boozman, pledged to follow court decisions and undertake thorough fact-finding. He said federal appellate courts are divided, making the situation complex. The Ninth, Sixth and Fourth Circuits sided with state jurisdiction, while the Third Circuit ruled for federal preemption. The CFTC is drafting rules for prediction markets as the commission and major operators including Kalshi and Polymarket are engaged in litigation. Rowland said rulemaking must balance public interest against the economic value of contracts.
Senators from both parties raised concerns about staff cuts and reduced enforcement personnel. CFTC staff numbers at the end of 2025 were 21% below the previous 10-year average. The commission's annual report also showed fewer enforcement actions in 2025 than in previous years. If confirmed, Anonick plans to review staff numbers, hiring plans and the need for technical expertise. Rowland called adequate staffing a priority and said he wants to learn about Selig's hiring plans. Both candidates said the commission needs more commissioners. If confirmed, Rowland's term would run through 13 April 2028, Anonick's through 19 June 2031; two seats would remain vacant, one reserved for a Democrat. The hearing adjourned without a vote. The committee and full Senate must approve the nominations; Boozman called for swift confirmation.