Skip to main content

CFTC Sports Contract Rule Draws Just 140 Comments as Tribal Groups Lead Opposition

Our write-up of a story first reported by Gambling Insider

CFTC Sports Contract Rule Draws Just 140 Comments as Tribal Groups Lead Opposition

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission received 140 comments by 18 November on its proposal to include sports event contracts in the definition of swaps. Most arrived in the final two days.

Tribal organisations, 43 states and Washington, D.C., the American Gaming Association, Utah authorities and Rep. Dina Titus of Nevada opposed the move. The National Congress of American Indians, representing around 300 tribal nations, demanded withdrawal: 'Simply labeling these wagers as swaps does not change their underlying nature as gambling.' Tribal associations in California, Oklahoma and Arizona warned that federal oversight threatens tribal sovereignty and casino revenue. The Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria said sports contracts on prediction markets 'threaten the entire economic foundation of tribal governments.'

Three of four tribes that partnered with Kalshi in October backed federal oversight. Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town in Oklahoma argued that regulated contracts and tribal gaming can coexist, citing a $60,000 Kalshi hedge used by a Los Angeles hospitality group against the Dodgers missing the World Series.

43 states and Washington, D.C., said the CFTC lacks authority to redefine sports wagering as financial derivatives. The AGA pointed to unequal treatment of functionally identical products and questioned market-size estimates: the CFTC cites $1.5 billion monthly, while turnover exceeded $39 billion in the first week of November alone. Boyd Gaming warned that a broad swap definition could eventually cover traditional casino games.

Prediction-market operators Kalshi, Polymarket US, Coinbase, Gemini, Novig, Underdog and others supported the proposal. Coinbase said event contracts are already swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, and the proposal merely confirms that. Underdog disclosed it has self-certified over 500 sports contracts as swaps, with its clearinghouse and futures commission merchant operating under CFTC regulation.

Comment volume fell sharply from earlier CFTC proceedings on prediction markets: over 3,500 in April and more than 1,400 in July. Then the NFL, NBA, players' unions, state regulators and academics weighed in; this time Titus was the only sitting lawmaker and a few academics, including professor Melinda Roth, submitted comments. Many individual supportive comments used identical language, pointing to a common template.

TG X Copied

Project sponsors

Companies that keep this analytics open