Playtech shares dropped 10% but recovered minutes before a New Jersey court hearing revealed Evolution had settled with law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky (C&K). The proceedings concern Evolution's defence against a motion to dismiss its defamation suit under New Jersey's anti-SLAPP statute, the Uniform Public Expression Protection Act.
The suit stems from a 2021 report claiming Evolution games were accessible in US-sanctioned and other prohibited jurisdictions. Publication wiped billions of dollars from the company's market cap. C&K appeared as the report's author, but court orders later unmasked the backers: private intelligence agency Black Cube and Evolution rival Playtech. Evolution sought to add Playtech as a defendant, but the court deferred that decision until the UPEPA challenge is resolved.
At the 17 November hearing C&K's lawyers disclosed a settlement with Evolution. Black Cube remains the sole defendant. The hearing had been scheduled for the previous day but was postponed, possibly while settlement talks concluded. The share-price crash and recovery ahead of the session may have followed a leak of incomplete information.
Black Cube's counsel requested the settlement agreement, arguing its terms and timing are relevant to trial. Judge John Porto said disclosure would require a separate order, with briefing likely within 30 days. Black Cube's lawyers called the deal a 'white flag of surrender' and said their understanding is there is no financial component — which, if true, would mean C&K withdrew without payment.
Black Cube's defence maintains the report rests on fact and is protected under UPEPA. Evidence cited includes attempts to access games in the disputed jurisdictions and covert recordings of Evolution staff and partners acknowledging activity in those markets. Black Cube also secured disclosure of Evolution's internal Spectrum Gaming investigation and argues it corroborates rather than clears the allegations. Evolution says the evidence is unreliable. If the court sides with Evolution, Playtech is likely to be joined as a defendant.