Skip to main content

Betfair wins negligence case as High Court clarifies duty of care

Our write-up of a story first reported by NEXT.io

Betfair wins negligence case as High Court clarifies duty of care

The High Court of England dismissed the Ashton family's negligence claim against Betfair but recognised that operators may bear limited liability for failing to protect vulnerable customers in cases where severe gambling disorder is foreseeable.

Luke Ashton died by suicide in 2021 after accumulating large debts from online betting. His widow Annie filed the claim on behalf of the estate and their two children against TSE Malta LP, the Flutter Entertainment entity operating Betfair Exchange. The family argued Betfair failed to recognise signs of gambling disorder and take action to prevent harm, which worsened Ashton's condition and contributed to his death.

Justice Swift dismissed the claim, concluding the evidence of gambling disorder was insufficient. The family's psychiatric expert, Dr John Barker, found Ashton met eight of nine DSM-5 diagnostic criteria for the disorder. The court accepted the assessment of Betfair's expert, Dr Humphrey Needham-Bennett, who found the evidence unconvincing. The judge held that betting records alone cannot establish the subjective experiences and motivations required for clinical diagnosis.

The ruling identified two circumstances under which an operator could be liable: where the operator knows the customer has been diagnosed with gambling disorder, or where the customer's behaviour is so extreme it demonstrates total loss of control. In such cases, the only appropriate response is to stop providing gambling services.

The court rejected the argument that the Gambling Commission's social responsibility requirements automatically create a civil duty of care. Section 24(8) of the Gambling Act 2005 states that breach of the Commission's code does not in itself give rise to civil liability. A Flutter UK & Ireland spokesperson offered condolences to the family while welcoming the court's decision.

Annie Ashton previously filed a separate challenge against the Gambling Commission over its refusal to take enforcement action against Betfair.

TG X Copied
Mentioned: NeBlaskBetfair

Project sponsors

Companies that keep this analytics open