U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon denied prediction market platform Novig's request to block New York authorities from enforcing state gambling and sports-wagering laws against the company. The court ruled that Novig's sports event contracts do not qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA).
McMahon said the contracts 'bear more than a passing resemblance to sports betting' and fall outside the CEA's swap definition. According to the ruling, Novig's contracts do not depend on events or contingencies associated with potential financial, economic or commercial consequences within the meaning of the act. New York can now require Novig to obtain a state gambling licence or stop trading sports event contracts.
Novig argued that federal commodities law preempts state regulation and that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has exclusive jurisdiction over event contracts as swaps. The judge rejected that argument at the preliminary injunction stage.
Ludlow Exchange LLC, the legal entity behind Novig, received contract market designation from the CFTC in June 2026 and began offering sports event contracts to New York customers in August. On August 5, the company sued New York Attorney General Letitia James and officials at the New York State Gaming Commission, challenging the state's authority to regulate its products under gambling laws.
This is the second such ruling by a New York federal judge this year. An earlier decision denied prediction market operator Kalshi's similar request to block state enforcement. Novig is pursuing litigation over its contracts' regulatory status in several other states. Kalshi, Polymarket and other prediction market operators face similar disputes over whether sports event contracts fall under federal commodities regulation or state gambling laws.
Gaming lawyer Daniel Wallach said the decision opens the way for New York authorities to pursue enforcement action against Novig through state court. He noted that federal courts within the Second Circuit have now issued 10 rulings in sports prediction market litigation, all favouring the states.