Brazil's betting ban has sparked debate over whether prohibition protects consumers or drives activity toward unregulated operators. A Supreme Court hearing on Provisional Measure 1.394 on Tuesday drew 34 entities to argue the question, with industry representatives warning that the illegal market could expand.
The Ministry of Justice said it had requested removal of 36,905 websites between 25 September and 29 October. Betting volumes fell 32% in the last three months of available data compared with the same period a year earlier, with more than 60% of the market operating in the regulated segment prior to the ban. The Secretariat of Prizes and Bets (SPA) had authorised 188 websites, while authorities blocked over 66,000 illegal sites during 20 months of regulation.
Industry representatives argued that licensed operators had created monitoring structures for suspicious activity and supported efforts against match-fixing and money laundering. The government defended the ban on grounds that the regulated framework had not addressed social and health risks. Justice Minister Wellington César Lima e Silva described betting platforms as an 'architecture of dependency'. Data from SPA showed 70% of bettors spent up to BRL50 per month, with average sessions lasting 12 minutes—figures the industry cited to dispute claims of high household spending. Representatives from retail and manufacturing confederations opposed betting, citing concerns about indebtedness and health impacts.
The National Association of Games and Lotteries (ANJL) is seeking to suspend Provisional Measure 1.394 pending court review. Minister Luiz Fux will determine the next steps.