sim_critic — Claude Code prompt: model audit
The sim_critic Claude Code prompt audits a Monte Carlo clinical-trial model against its evidence, code, results, and report. It flags calibration issues and returns a verdict with ranked change requests.
no license ★ 654 updated 2026-11-09
/plugin marketplace add anthropics/life-sciences
/plugin install clinical-trial-forecast@life-sciencesWhat sim_critic does
The prompt reviews a Monte Carlo model for a clinical trial. It checks parameter estimates against source evidence, examines statistical logic and simulation results, and assesses reproducibility and report clarity. It also looks for duplicate adjustments and shifts in either direction.
The review uses project files such as sim/params.json, sim/workspace/simulate.py, sim/workspace/results.json, plus evidence from intake/, knowledge/, topics/, analyses/, and research/. It works by reading files only; it does not access the web or run code.
The output contains section scores, ranked requests for changes, open research questions, and a critique in Markdown of up to 1,500 words. Its verdict is accept, revise_params, revise_code, or revise_both.
What it helps with
- compare model parameters with trial evidence
- detect overlapping adjustments that distort PTS
- check simulation logic and reproducibility
- rank changes needed in the model or report
Example prompts for the agent
- Audit the clinical-trial model using the project files and return a verdict with ranked requests.
- Check whether any parameters count the same effect twice and assess the impact on PTS.
- Compare the simulation with the evidence and write a critique for the committee.
How to install sim_critic
1Plugin marketplace
/plugin marketplace add anthropics/life-sciences/plugin install clinical-trial-forecast@life-sciences2Manually: put the files in place
.claude/commands/sim_critic.mdHow to use
Paste the text at the start of a chat or into project instructions
Questions about sim_critic
How do I install sim_critic in Claude Code?
Add the marketplace with /plugin marketplace add anthropics/life-sciences, then install the plugin with /plugin install clinical-trial-forecast@life-sciences. The command file is at .claude/commands/sim_critic.md.
What does sim_critic do?
It audits a clinical-trial Monte Carlo model, covering its parameters, code, results, and reproducibility. The response includes a verdict, ranked change requests, and research questions.
Which files does sim_critic review?
It reads model files under sim/ and supporting evidence from intake/, knowledge/, topics/, analyses/, and research/. It does not execute code or access the web.