Skip to main content

Bill 55 debate continues after ECJ sidesteps EU law question

Our write-up of a story first reported by iGaming Business

Bill 55 debate continues after ECJ sidesteps EU law question

The European Court of Justice declined to rule on Malta's Bill 55 compatibility with EU law, calling the case inadmissible. The court found that the dispute between Austrian litigation funder Spielerschutz Sigma and its legal adviser was a matter of professional malpractice, not EU law interpretation.

Bill 55, adopted in Malta in 2023, bars recognition and enforcement of foreign court judgments, including claims against operators active in unlicensed markets. Spielerschutz Sigma had backed litigation in which Austrian players sought refunds from Maltese-licensed operators offering services without local licences. After Malta refused recognition of an Austrian judgment, the Austrian court referred questions to the ECJ.

Felix Hohenthanner, a lawyer at Austrian firm Rapani Rechtsanwälte, called the ECJ decision expected: the case did not meet procedural requirements for referral to the ECJ. Terence Cassar, partner at Maltese firm GTG, agreed that the underlying dispute was essentially a legal malpractice lawsuit.

The dismissal leaves the question of Bill 55's compatibility with EU law unresolved. Hohenthanner noted that Austrian players face growing difficulty recovering funds unless Maltese operators hold assets in other EU countries. Maltese officials maintain the law rests on a public policy position adopted over 20 years ago, allowing member states to make exceptions to judgment recognition rules.

Malta's Court of Appeal referred separate questions to the ECJ on Bill 55 compatibility in October. Hohenthanner suggested that case could produce a definitive ECJ ruling on the merits, possibly in 2027 or later. The Austrian Association for Betting and Gaming (OVWG) is monitoring developments and potential implications for player claims cases in Austria.

TG X Copied

Project sponsors

Companies that keep this analytics open