Skip to main content

AI Overviews are taking over the map pack. Here’s what I found

Our write-up of a story first reported by Semrush Blog

AI Overviews are taking over the map pack. Here’s what I found

An SEO agency tested 480 high-intent local searches across 12 US cities between September and November 2026. AI Overviews appeared on 38% in the first round and 99% in the second, roughly two months later.

The agency searched 10 service categories—electricians, plumbers, dentists, lawyers, restaurants—each as a bare keyword and a conversational phrase. Worcester, Massachusetts showed the steepest shift: from one AIO to twelve searches. Philadelphia went from four to nineteen. Of 292 AIOs that appeared across all 480 searches, 106 persisted when the same searches ran again.

AI Overview replaces the map pack

In the final round, AIOs appeared without a separate map pack on 79 of 80 searches. Local businesses now show as cards inside the overview instead. Where AIOs and the pack shared a page earlier—145 searches—they recommended different businesses 79% of the time. On about one in five searches, the AIO named no businesses from the pack at all. The overview showed roughly five businesses per result versus the pack's three.

The new card layout left room for smaller operators. About one in five cards belonged to a business with fewer than 50 reviews. One plumber with a single review appeared first on an emergency plumber search in Cottonwood, Arizona.

Ranking the web doesn't guarantee the overview

More than a third of the businesses the AIO recommended—373 of 1,023—did not appear on the first page of Google. Even after AIOs replaced the pack, 36% of named businesses ranked outside page one. The overview drew on other signals: Google Business Profiles, directory listings, mentions on other sites.

Conversational searches received AIOs first. On the first pass, 66% of conversational queries showed an overview compared with 24% of bare ones. On the second pass, bare searches caught up to 66%. The gap appeared in 19 of 24 market rounds.

TG X Copied

Project sponsors

Companies that keep this analytics open