Skip to main content

Did Kalshi’s Federal Court Strategy Push Utah Toward Criminal Prosecution?

Our write-up of a story first reported by Gambling Insider

Did Kalshi’s Federal Court Strategy Push Utah Toward Criminal Prosecution?

Utah has filed 14 criminal counts each against Kalshi, CEO Tarek Mansour and COO Luana Lopes Lara, including a second-degree felony for pattern of unlawful activity and 12 third-degree felonies for online gambling promotion. The charges follow an August 4 ruling by US District Judge Robert J. Shelby holding that the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt Utah's gambling laws as applied to the platform's sports contracts.

Former CFTC special counsel Peter Sanchez Guarda told Gambling Insider that states are increasingly turning to criminal prosecution as a response to operators challenging their authority in federal court. Criminal cases carry a higher burden of proof but are harder for defendants to transfer to federal jurisdiction, unlike civil proceedings.

Utah's complaint describes an undercover operation between September 13 and 26, in which an Attorney General investigator opened a Kalshi account and placed 12 sports wagers totalling approximately $115 across NFL, college football, MLB, MLS and NHL events. Prosecutors allege Kalshi charged transaction fees ranging from $0.03 to $0.78 and knowingly continued accepting bets from Utah residents after the Shelby ruling. The undercover wagers form the basis of the counts against both the company and its executives. Prosecutors drew on public statements from Mansour and Lopes Lara describing their control over strategy, operations and personnel to establish their individual liability under Utah Code § 76-2-205, which requires proof of intentional conduct.

On October 29, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission filed an emergency motion seeking to block Utah's enforcement proceedings, arguing the agency's regulatory authority preempts state action. The motion is before Shelby, whose previous ruling weighs against Kalshi's defence. Utah is the second state to pursue criminal charges against the platform, following Arizona, where the CFTC secured a preliminary injunction in May. A separate civil case filed by Utah seeks to restrict the platform's contracts and recover estimated fees of between $30.6 million and $61.2 million collected from 32,940 accounts with Utah addresses as of February 2026. Kalshi dismissed the charges as political overreach and expressed confidence in court victory.

TG X Copied

Project sponsors

Companies that keep this analytics open