The UK Gambling Commission found that 45% of illegal gambling website users scored eight or higher on the Problem Gambling Severity Index, compared with 6% of licensed operator customers. Among those scoring between three and seven on the index, illegal users accounted for 17%, versus 9% of licensed customers.
The regulator did not establish whether illegal gambling directly causes greater harm. The research revealed substantial market overlap: 91% of individuals with repeated transactions on illegal platforms also gambled through licensed operators. Among 122 people with two or more detected illegal payments, average monthly licensed transactions remained stable at 24.8 before their first illegal payment and 23.7 afterward. 'Illegal gambling is embedded within existing gambling behavior rather than triggering a sustained shift away from the licensed market,' the report concluded.
The analysis covered 157.2 million banking transactions from approximately 38,000 individuals between July 2018 and July 2026, supplied by YouGov. Researchers identified 3,426 suspected illegal gambling transactions involving 179 individuals. The commission acknowledged significant limitations in detection, as unlicensed operators rarely appeared under their actual names in banking records; investigators relied on merchant categories and transaction codes to trace suspected payments.