Skip to main content

How Cardmarket wins search by knowing its community better than anyone

Our write-up of a story first reported by Semrush Blog

How Cardmarket wins search by knowing its community better than anyone

Organic traffic can no longer be won through content volume and link buying alone. In markets where users understand the product well, search engines increasingly favour brands that speak the community's language, address real scenarios and become sources for AI-generated answers. This is especially visible in high-engagement verticals: collectibles, iGaming, betting, fintech, gaming, crypto and affiliate services.

A strong example of this approach is community-first SEO: a strategy where promotion is built not around abstract keywords but around audience interests, behaviour and terminology. This approach delivers stable organic growth and visibility in AI search — ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and other systems that select sources with clear expertise and structured data.

Why traditional SEO increasingly hits a ceiling

Many teams still build SEO the old way: gather keywords, cluster them, write content, place links, wait for growth. This works in some niches, but results are becoming less predictable. Several reasons stand out.

SERP has become crowded: marketplaces, aggregators, Reddit-like platforms, video, AI blocks, local results. User queries have grown longer and more specific. People no longer search for 'best casino bonus' but 'casino with fast card withdrawal Kazakhstan no verification'. AI systems take a share of informational traffic but offer new opportunities to those they cite or use as sources. Content without real experience is easily recognised by users and algorithms alike.

In iGaming and affiliate this is especially critical. If a site writes 'top casinos 2026' without real criteria, geo nuances, payment methods, limits, wagering terms and user cases, it competes with thousands of identical pages. But if a resource understands that audiences in Uzbekistan ask about P2P deposits, players in Kazakhstan about Kaspi and KYC speed, and high rollers about withdrawal limits and VIP cashback, that is a different level of SEO.

What community-first SEO looks like in practice

Community-first SEO is not 'run a Telegram channel' or 'collect reviews'. It is a way of making SEO decisions through the lens of the community: how users actually frame the problem, what words and slang they use, what fears block conversion, which selection criteria matter more than brand promises, and what data they want to see before clicking, registering or depositing.

In traditional SEO a page is built for a query. In community-first SEO a page is built for a scenario. Instead of a separate article 'What is revshare', create a practical guide: 'Revshare in iGaming: when CPA is better, how to calculate LTV and where affiliates lose money'. Such material closes not only informational intent but real pain points for webmasters: choosing a model, evaluating an offer, fraud risks, hold, statistics transparency.

How to gather insights from the community

The main mistake is assuming the team 'already knows' the audience. In reality SEO specialists, content managers and product teams often live inside their dashboards, not in actual user context.

Sources of insight can be simple: Telegram chats for affiliates and webmasters, forums on iGaming, betting, SEO and affiliate marketing, comments under offer reviews, internal support tickets, account manager chats with partners, Google and Yandex search suggestions, reviews on Trustpilot and niche directories, questions in sales calls and demos, CRM data on reasons for rejection.

Do not just collect phrases. Group them by meaning. For an affiliate network you might identify clusters such as trust ('do they pay', 'is there shaving', 'how do they verify leads'), economics ('CPA or revshare', 'what EPC', 'how to calculate ROI'), traffic ('do they accept Facebook', 'can I use push', 'is branded PPC allowed'), operations ('what is the hold', 'how fast are withdrawals', 'is there a postback') and geo ('best offers for KZ', 'what works in LATAM', 'payment methods for India').

Based on these clusters you build a content architecture far more accurate than standard keyword research.

Content that wins: data, language and scenarios

Search engines and AI tools favour not just long texts but content that is easy to interpret. Three elements matter.

Real data instead of general words. A page called 'Best betting offers' is weak if it only has descriptions. Much stronger is a table with parameters: geo, payment model (CPA, CPL, revshare, hybrid), minimum deposit, allowed traffic sources, hold, CR for registration and deposit, average EPC, presence of caps, creative requirements. Even if some data cannot be fully disclosed, you can provide ranges, updated statuses or explanations. This increases trust and makes the page useful for AI output.

Audience language. If webmasters say 'CR dropped after KYC', do not replace it with 'the rate of successful registrations decreased following the identification procedure'. Expertise in affiliate marketing is often read through language. But balance matters: slang should help, not turn material into a closed chat. Best approach is to use the term and immediately give a practical explanation.

Content for specific funnel stages. Community-first SEO works well when content covers the entire decision chain: a beginner searches for basic concepts ('what is CPA in arbitrage'), a practitioner compares ('CPA vs revshare in iGaming'), a media buyer selects ('offers for Tier-2 with push traffic'), a team lead calculates economics ('how to forecast ROI in a betting funnel'), a partner checks reliability ('how to tell if an affiliate programme shaves'). If a site covers only the top of the funnel it gets traffic without money. If only the bottom it hits limited demand. You need a connected system of pages.

AI visibility: why community content gets cited more often

AI search changes the rules. A user may not visit the site if they get an answer immediately. But this does not mean SEO is dead. The goal shifts: become a source AI trusts.

For this, content must be structured (lists, tables, FAQ, clear definitions), updated (dates, current terms, notes on changes), unique in data (own observations, statistics, cases), clear in authorship (who writes, why they can be trusted) and internally linked (so AI sees thematic depth).

Growth in AI-referred sessions of 200% is possible not from one article but from a systematic knowledge base. When a site answers related questions better than competitors many times over, it becomes a likely source for generative answers.

In iGaming this could be a database on geo, payment methods, bonus mechanics, KYC, RTP, local restrictions, traffic types and payout models. For an affiliate portal, a directory of networks, offers, verticals, trackers, antidetect browsers, spy services and traffic sources.

How to implement community-first SEO in an affiliate project

The strategy can be rolled out without a large editorial team. The key is to build a process.

Create an audience map. Do not write 'for affiliates' in general. Segment the audience: solo media buyer, affiliate team, SEO affiliate, PPC specialist, ASO and influencer traffic, affiliate manager, iGaming operator, owner of an affiliate programme. Each segment has different queries and KPI. A webmaster cares about payouts and CR, an operator about traffic quality and NGR, an affiliate manager about caps and partner retention.

Turn questions into content clusters. Take 50 to 100 real questions from chats, support and sales communications. Then group them into clusters and build not separate scattered articles but hubs. Example hub: 'iGaming offers for arbitrage'. Inside: how to choose an offer, CPA vs revshare, Tier-1 Tier-2 Tier-3 geo, allowed traffic sources, typical reasons for lead rejection, how to calculate ROI, checklist before launch. Such a hub ranks better, retains users better and provides more internal links.

Add expert texture. Even two or three practical blocks sharply increase material value: a mini case study of a launch, a comparison table, a checklist, typical mistakes, an affiliate manager comment, an ROI calculation example, if-then scenarios. For example: 'If registration CR is high but FTD is low, check payment methods, the bonus screen and whether the creative promise matches the landing page'. This is far more useful than a paragraph about 'the importance of funnel optimisation'.

Update pages like a product. Community-first SEO cannot be launched once. Niches change fast: payment methods get cut off, offers close, sources ban accounts, KYC requirements tighten. For key pages maintain regular updates: once a month for commercial pages and reviews, once a quarter for evergreen guides, after major changes for geo, payments, regulation and traffic sources. Updating the date without factual changes does not help. You need new data, clarifications, removal of outdated material and expanded FAQ.

Metrics: how to know the strategy is working

Judging community-first SEO by positions alone is a mistake. Look wider: growth in organic traffic from long-tail queries, number of pages receiving impressions, share of branded and non-branded queries, CTR in SERP, page depth and returns, assisted conversions, leads, registrations, connection requests, AI-referred sessions from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and other sources, brand mentions in AI answers and third-party discussions.

For affiliate and iGaming it is especially important to link SEO to business metrics: not just 'the page delivered 10,000 visits' but 'the page brought 120 webmaster registrations, 18 activated offers, 5 delivered positive ROI'.

The main takeaway

Strong SEO today is built not around text but around market understanding. Those who know their community better gather keywords more accurately, spot new intents faster, create useful content and become sources for AI search.

For affiliate marketing and iGaming this is especially relevant. The audience here is experienced, distrustful and quickly reads superficial content. Winners are not those who publish more articles but those who answer real market questions better than competitors — with data, examples and honest expertise.

Project sponsors

Companies that keep this analytics open