Massachusetts residents are filing complaints about prediction market platforms with the state's gambling regulator, only to be redirected to a federal agency. A Massachusetts Gaming Commission (MGC) spokesperson confirmed that dozens of emails have reached the team's general inbox, each one met with the same reply: the MGC does not regulate prediction markets and refers people to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). Whether those referrals lead to investigations, refunds, or any other outcome remains unclear.
MGC Chair Jordan Maynard raised the issue before Congress in November, telling lawmakers the problem stems from how similar the two products appear to consumers. 'We have basically two sets of standards for a product that looks exactly the same to the end user,' he said. His testimony also pointed to concrete differences in how the two regimes protect consumers: licensed Massachusetts sportsbooks have returned nearly $10 million to customers following operator errors, and the MGC has completed 39 enforcement actions carrying monetary penalties, with operators paying more than $1 million to the Commonwealth. Maynard argued the CFTC's framework does not require equivalent protections.
College athletes are another fault line. Massachusetts sportsbooks cannot accept proposition bets on individual college players, but prediction market platforms including Kalshi offer contracts tied to individual athlete outcomes. The age gap is similarly direct: state sportsbooks are restricted to customers 21 and older, while Kalshi generally permits eligible adults aged 18 and older to trade sports-related event contracts.
Massachusetts obtained a preliminary injunction against Kalshi in January 2026, alleging its sports contracts constitute unlicensed wagering under state law. Kalshi is challenging that ruling, arguing its contracts fall under federal commodities jurisdiction. Maynard asked Congress to preserve state and tribal authority over sports wagering, ban proposition bets on college players, and fund independent research into gambling-related harm. His summary of the dispute was blunt: 'Illegality is not innovation.'