Federal deputy Ricardo Abrão (PSDB-RJ) has submitted Bill No. 5,502/2026, titled the 'Full Restitution and Compensation for Bettors Law', to Brazil's Chamber of Deputies. Referred on 12 November to the Consumer Protection Committee (CDC) and the Constitution, Justice and Citizenship Committee (CCJC), the proposal would require betting operators to reimburse customer losses accumulated under the suspended Bets regime. The bill covers net losses, unreturned balances, unpaid winnings, cancelled bets and unauthorised transactions, with operators obliged to provide detailed transaction statements within 10 working days. Abrão argues that the uncontrolled expansion of the market harmed vulnerable Brazilians, and that operators and their controlling shareholders should bear the financial consequences rather than taxpayers.
Legal pushback
The proposal drew immediate criticism from Udo Seckelmann, partner at Bichara e Motta Advogados, who called it 'a genuine legal aberration'. Seckelmann told SBC Notícias Brasil that the bill seeks to force operators to return money lost through lawful bets, ignoring the inherent risk in betting contracts. The financial exposure is potentially vast—operators could be required to reimburse billions of reais—while the operational demand is impractical: reconstructing transaction histories for millions of users within a 10-day window is practically impossible. Seckelmann warned of substantial constitutional obstacles, pointing to potential violations of legal certainty, proportionality, freedom of enterprise and the protection of validly completed legal acts. If the bill passes, he said, it will be challenged in court.
Context
The proposal emerges as the Bets regime remains suspended following President Lula's order of 25 September 2026. Justice Luiz Fux of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) has suspended lower-court proceedings challenging the betting ban. The Supreme Court will rule on the constitutionality of the ban, while Congress must separately decide whether to convert the presidential order into federal law.