К основному содержанию
скилл CX Codex

create-adr — скилл для Claude Code: что делает и как установить

Скилл create-adr для Claude Code — фиксирует принятые архитектурные решения в формате ADR, сохраняя контекст для будущих разработчиков.

CC-BY-4.0 ★ 7 191 обновлён 2026-10-24

Установить в Claude Code · Через Skills CLI (Vercel) Все способы и платформы ↓
npx skills add tech-leads-club/agent-skills --skill create-adr -a claude-code
Открыть на GitHub

Что делает create-adr

Скилл создаёт архитектурные записи (Architecture Decision Records) прямо в репозитории проекта. Ассистент запрашивает суть решения, контекст, статус и последствия. Поддерживаются три формата: MADR с разбором альтернатив, минималистичный Nygard и сжатый Y-Statement. По умолчанию генератор использует MADR.

Инструмент проверяет папки docs/adr/, docs/decisions/ или .adr/, определяет максимальный порядковый номер и присваивает следующий индекс. Документ формируется на языке пользователя с сохранением английских технических терминов. Готовый файл предлагается сохранить по пути docs/adr/{NNN}-{kebab-case-title}.md.

Скилл рассчитан строго на зафиксированные решения. Если выбор ещё не сделан и требуется обсуждение вариантов, автор предписывает использовать процесс RFC.

Какие задачи решает

  • зафиксировать выбор технологии или архитектурного подхода
  • сохранить аргументы и отклонённые варианты в формате MADR
  • присвоить следующий порядковый номер новой записи в каталоге ADR
  • структурировать последствия принятого инженерного решения

Примеры запросов агенту

  • Зафиксируй через ADR наше решение перейти на PostgreSQL для основного хранилища
  • Создай ADR по выбору Redis для сессий, используй формат Nygard
  • Добавь архитектурную запись о разделении монолита на сервисы

Как установить create-adr

1Через Skills CLI (Vercel)

npx skills add tech-leads-club/agent-skills --skill create-adr -a claude-code

2Вручную: положить файлы

~/.claude/skills/create-adr/SKILL.md

Папка скилла целиком; для одного проекта — .claude/skills/create-adr/

По шагам, с командами для каждой платформы: Как установить скилл в Claude Code: пять способов

Вопросы о create-adr

Как установить create-adr в Claude Code?

Выполните команду npx skills add tech-leads-club/agent-skills --skill create-adr -a claude-code. Файл навыка сохраняется по пути ~/.claude/skills/create-adr/SKILL.md.

В чём разница между ADR и RFC в этом скилле?

RFC создаётся до утверждения решения для открытого обсуждения. ADR фиксирует уже сделанный выбор, становится неизменяемым документом и укладывается в 200–500 слов.

Какие форматы записей поддерживает create-adr?

Доступны три варианта: MADR со сравнением альтернатив, классический короткий шаблон Nygard и сверхкомпактный формат Y-Statement в один абзац.

Исходный текст

SKILL.md · CC-BY-4.0
---
name: create-adr
description: Creates Architecture Decision Records (ADRs) to document significant architectural choices and their rationale for future team members. Use when the user says "write an ADR", "document this decision", "record why we chose X", "add an architecture decision record", "create an ADR for", or wants to capture the reasoning behind a technical choice so the team understands it later. Do NOT use when the decision hasn't been made yet (use create-rfc instead), for implementation planning (use technical-design-doc-creator), or for general documentation.
license: CC-BY-4.0
metadata:
  author: Tech Leads Club - github.com/tech-leads-club
  version: '1.0.0'
---

# ADR Creator

You are an expert in creating Architecture Decision Records (ADRs) — concise, durable documents that capture the context, decision, and consequences of significant architectural choices so future team members understand *why* things are the way they are.

## When to Use This Skill

Use this skill when:

- User asks to "write an ADR", "create an ADR", "add an architecture decision record"
- User wants to "document why we chose X", "record this decision", "capture this architectural choice"
- A significant technical decision has been made (or is being finalized) and needs to be recorded
- The team wants to preserve the reasoning behind a choice for future engineers
- User asks "why did we choose X" and the answer should be written down permanently

Do NOT use for:

- Decisions not yet made — use `create-rfc` to drive the decision process first
- Implementation planning after the decision — use `technical-design-doc-creator`
- Simple configuration choices or trivial code decisions
- Meeting notes or general documentation

## ADR vs RFC — Critical Distinction

| Aspect | ADR | RFC |
|--------|-----|-----|
| **Timing** | Decision already made (or being finalized) | Before the decision (seeking input) |
| **Purpose** | Record for future team members | Proposal seeking approval |
| **Audience** | Engineers joining months or years later | Current stakeholders |
| **Length** | Short — 200–500 words | Long — thorough comparison |
| **Mutability** | Immutable — superseded, never edited | Iterative — evolves during review |
| **Tone** | Historical record | Deliberative proposal |

If the user says "I need to decide whether to do X" → use `create-rfc`.
If the user says "We decided to do X, let me document it" → use this skill.

## Language Adaptation

**CRITICAL**: Always generate the ADR in the **same language as the user's request**. Detect the language automatically.

- Keep technical terms in English when appropriate (e.g., "ADR", "API", "microservices")
- All section headers and content should be in the user's language
- Company/product names remain in original form

## ADR Format Selection

Three formats are widely used. Detect the right one from context, or ask:

| Format | Best For | Length |
|--------|----------|--------|
| **MADR** (Markdown ADR) | Teams that want structured options comparison | Medium |
| **Nygard** (original) | Minimal, fast recording; obvious decisions | Short |
| **Y-Statement** | Inline documentation, very compact contexts | One paragraph |

Default to **MADR** unless the user specifies otherwise or the decision is very simple.

---

## Interactive Workflow

### Step 1: Gather Context (if not provided)

If the user provides minimal context, use **AskQuestion** to collect essential information:

```json
{
  "title": "ADR Information",
  "questions": [
    {
      "id": "adr_decision",
      "prompt": "What was the decision made? (e.g., 'Use PostgreSQL for primary storage')",
      "options": [
        { "id": "free_text", "label": "I'll describe it in my next message" }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "adr_format",
      "prompt": "Which ADR format would you like to use?",
      "options": [
        { "id": "madr", "label": "MADR — structured, with options comparison (recommended)" },
        { "id": "nygard", "label": "Nygard — minimal: Context / Decision / Consequences" },
        { "id": "y_statement", "label": "Y-Statement — single paragraph, very compact" }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "adr_status",
      "prompt": "What is the current status of this decision?",
      "options": [
        { "id": "accepted", "label": "Accepted — decision is final" },
        { "id": "proposed", "label": "Proposed — decision is being finalized" },
        { "id": "deprecated", "label": "Deprecated — this approach is no longer recommended" },
        { "id": "superseded", "label": "Superseded — replaced by a newer decision" }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "adr_supersedes",
      "prompt": "Does this ADR supersede a previous decision?",
      "options": [
        { "id": "yes", "label": "Yes — I'll provide the ADR number/title" },
        { "id": "no", "label": "No — this is a new decision" }
      ]
    }
  ]
}
```

### Step 2: Validate Mandatory Fields

**MANDATORY fields — ask if missing**:

- **Decision title** (noun phrase, not a question — e.g., "Use Redis for session storage")
- **Date** of the decision (or today's date)
- **Status** (Accepted / Proposed / Deprecated / Superseded)
- **Context** — the forces, constraints, and situation that made this decision necessary
- **The decision itself** — what was chosen and why
- **Consequences** — what becomes easier, harder, or different as a result

**RECOMMENDED fields**:
- **Decision drivers** — the key criteria or constraints
- **Options considered** — what alternatives were evaluated
- **Pros/cons per option** — honest trade-off assessment
- **Decision outcome rationale** — why this option over the others
- **Links** — related ADRs, RFCs, tickets, or documentation

If any mandatory fields are missing, ask IN THE USER'S LANGUAGE before generating the document.

### Step 3: Assign ADR Number

Scan the existing ADR directory for the next sequential number:

1. Check if an ADR directory exists (`docs/adr/`, `docs/decisions/`, `.adr/`, or `adr/`)
2. Find the highest existing number
3. Assign the next number (e.g., if ADR-007 exists, this becomes ADR-008)
4. If no directory exists, start at ADR-001 and suggest creating the directory

### Step 4: Generate the ADR

Generate the ADR following the format selected in Step 1.

### Step 5: Offer File Placement

After generating, ask where to save it:

```
ADR Created: "ADR-{NNN}: {Title}"

Suggested file path: docs/adr/{NNN}-{kebab-case-title}.md

Would you like me to:
1. Save it to docs/adr/ (recommended convention)
2. Save it to a different location
3. Just show the content (I'll place it manually)
```

---

## Document Templates

### MADR Format (Default)

```markdown
# ADR-{NNN}: {Title}

- **Date**: YYYY-MM-DD
- **Status**: Accepted | Proposed | Deprecated | Superseded by [ADR-NNN]({link})
- **Deciders**: {who was involved in the decision}
- **Tags**: {optional: architecture, security, performance, database, etc.}

## Context and Problem Statement

{Describe the context and the problem or question that led to this decision.
2–4 sentences. What situation forced this choice?}

## Decision Drivers

- {Driver 1 — e.g., "Must support 10k concurrent users"}
- {Driver 2 — e.g., "Team has no Go experience"}
- {Driver 3 — e.g., "Must be deployable on-premise"}

## Considered Options

- {Option A}
- {Option B}
- {Option C — "Do nothing / status quo" when relevant}

## Decision Outcome

Chosen option: **"{Option A}"**, because {concise rationale tied to decision drivers}.

### Positive Consequences

- {Benefit 1}
- {Benefit 2}

### Negative Consequences

- {Trade-off 1 — be honest}
- {Trade-off 2}

## Pros and Cons of the Options

### {Option A} ✅ Chosen

- ✅ {Pro 1}
- ✅ {Pro 2}
- ❌ {Con 1}

### {Option B}

- ✅ {Pro 1}
- ❌ {Con 1}
- ❌ {Con 2}

### {Option C}

- ✅ {Pro 1}
- ❌ {Con 1}

## Links

- {Related ADR, RFC, ticket, or documentation}
- Supersedes: [ADR-{NNN}: {Title}]({link}) (if applicable)
- Superseded by: [ADR-{NNN}: {Title}]({link}) (if applicable)
```

---

### Nygard Format (Minimal)

```markdown
# ADR-{NNN}: {Title}

## Status

Accepted | Proposed | Deprecated | Superseded by ADR-{NNN}

## Context

{What is the situation that led to this decision?
What forces are at play — technical, business, organizational?
What constraints exist? 2–5 sentences.}

## Decision

{What did we decide to do?
State it directly, in active voice: "We will use X" or "We decided to adopt Y."
Include a brief rationale — why this option over the alternatives.}

## Consequences

{What becomes easier or better as a result?}
{What becomes harder or worse? Be honest about trade-offs.}
{What new concerns or constraints does this introduce?}
```

---

### Y-Statement Format (Compact)

```markdown
# ADR-{NNN}: {Title}

**Date**: YYYY-MM-DD | **Status**: Accepted

In the context of **{situation/use case}**,
facing **{concern or constraint}**,
we decided **{the option chosen}**,
to achieve **{quality attribute or goal}**,
accepting **{the downside or trade-off}**.

**Deciders**: {names or roles}
**Links**: {related ADRs, tickets}
```

---

## ADR Quality Checklist

Before finalizing, verify:

- [ ] **Title** is a noun phrase describing the decision (not a question, not a vague label)
- [ ] **Date** is included (decisions without dates lose context quickly)
- [ ] **Status** is set correctly — Accepted, Proposed, Deprecated, or Superseded
- [ ] **Context** explains the *forces* that made this decision necessary, not just what was done
- [ ] **Decision** is stated directly and tied to the context
- [ ] **Consequences** include honest trade-offs — not just positives
- [ ] **Options** (MADR format) include at least 2 alternatives actually considered
- [ ] **Supersedes / superseded by** links are included when applicable
- [ ] **File** follows naming convention: `NNN-kebab-case-title.md`
- [ ] **Number** is sequential in the ADR directory

---

## ADR File Naming Convention

```
docs/adr/
├── 001-use-postgresql-for-primary-storage.md
├── 002-adopt-event-driven-architecture.md
├── 003-replace-jenkins-with-github-actions.md   ← supersedes ADR-001 if relevant
└── README.md                                     ← optional index
```

- Zero-padded numbers: `001`, `002`, ... `099`, `100`
- Kebab-case title
- `.md` extension
- Common directories: `docs/adr/`, `docs/decisions/`, `adr/`, `.adr/`

---

## Common Anti-Patterns to Avoid

### Title as a Question

**BAD**: `# ADR-001: Should we use PostgreSQL?`

**GOOD**: `# ADR-001: Use PostgreSQL for Primary Storage`

Titles should record the decision, not the question. Future readers need to know *what was decided*, not what was considered.

---

### Vague Context

**BAD**:
```
We needed a database and chose PostgreSQL.
```

**GOOD**:
```
Our application requires a relational database with strong ACID guarantees.
The team has deep PostgreSQL experience. MySQL was evaluated but lacks
native support for JSONB columns, which our schema design requires.
Our cloud provider (AWS) offers managed PostgreSQL via RDS at acceptable cost.
```

Context should explain the *forces* — why wasn't the alternative obviously better?

---

### Consequences Without Trade-offs

**BAD**:
```
## Consequences
PostgreSQL is fast and reliable.
```

**GOOD**:
```
## Consequences
- Enables JSONB columns and advanced indexing for our query patterns
- Team expertise means fast onboarding and fewer operational surprises
- Adds operational burden compared to a managed NoSQL service
- Schema migrations require careful planning in a relational model
```

Honest trade-offs are what make ADRs valuable years later.

---

### Editing Instead of Superseding

**BAD**: Editing an old ADR to change the decision after the fact.

**GOOD**: Creating a new ADR with `Status: Superseded by ADR-{NNN}` on the old one and linking back.

ADRs are historical records. The old decision was correct *given what was known at the time*. Superseding preserves that context.

---

### Missing the "Why Not" Rationale

**BAD**:
```
## Decision
We will use Redis for session storage.
```

**GOOD**:
```
## Decision
We will use Redis for session storage. We considered storing sessions in PostgreSQL
(already in our stack) but Redis's built-in TTL support and in-memory performance
make it significantly better suited for high-frequency session reads. The operational
cost of an additional service is justified by the simplified session expiry logic.
```

The rationale is *why this option and not the others* — not just what was chosen.

---

## Important Notes

- **ADRs are immutable** — never edit the decision. Supersede with a new ADR.
- **Short is better** — 200–500 words is ideal. If it needs to be longer, move detail to a linked TDD or RFC.
- **Context ages** — always date the ADR; what seems obvious now won't be in 3 years.
- **Honest consequences** — a one-sided ADR loses credibility. Future engineers will hit the downsides regardless.
- **Link everything** — related ADRs, the RFC that drove the decision, tickets, PR references.
- **Language adaptation** — always write in the user's language.
- **Number sequentially** — check the directory before assigning a number.

## Example Prompts that Trigger This Skill

### English
- "Write an ADR for using PostgreSQL as our primary database"
- "Document our decision to adopt GraphQL"
- "Create an ADR for moving our frontend to Next.js"
- "I need to record why we chose Kafka over RabbitMQ"
- "Add an architecture decision record for our authentication approach"

### Portuguese
- "Escreva um ADR sobre a decisão de usar PostgreSQL"
- "Documente a decisão de adotar GraphQL no projeto"
- "Crie um ADR explicando por que escolhemos Kafka"

### Spanish
- "Escribe un ADR sobre la decisión de usar PostgreSQL"
- "Documenta la decisión de adoptar microservicios"
- "Crea un ADR explicando por qué elegimos Next.js"

© Tech Leads Club - github.com/tech-leads-club · CC-BY-4.0 · tech-leads-club/agent-skills

Похожие скиллы

Все скиллы по теме «Тексты и документация» →
adr-create ruvnet Скилл adr-create для Claude Code и пяти других платформ создаёт Architecture Decision Record с порядковым номером, регистрирует его в графе AgentDB и связывает с похожими решениями. Запускается на команду с названием решения. CX Codex +1 743установок adr-drafting giuseppe-trisciuoglio Скилл adr-drafting опрашивает разработчика об архитектурном решении, находит соглашения в репозитории и создаёт новый markdown-документ формата ADR. Пригодится при смене стека или разделении сервисов. CX Codex +1 3 700установок ADR Generator официальный github Субагент ADR Generator оформляет архитектурные решения в формате ADR и сохраняет их в репозиторий. Он проверяет входящие данные, нумерует документы и фиксирует альтернативы с последствиями. CX Codex +1 ★ 41 430звёзд репо adr ncklrs Помогает вести записи архитектурных решений по методологии MADR и Олафа Циммермана прямо в чате с агентом. CX Codex +1 146установок adr-writing existential-birds Скилл adr-writing для Claude Code, который оформляет архитектурные решения в документы ADR по шаблону MADR и проверяет их полноту по чек-листу E.C.A.D.R. Работает также в Codex, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Gemini CLI и OpenCode. CX Codex +1 254установок adr-decision-extraction existential-birds Скилл adr-decision-extraction извлекает архитектурные решения из чатов и расшифровок, чтобы подготовить материал для ADR. Он распознаёт выбор технологий, компромиссы и явные метки. CX Codex +1 144установок

Из того же набора130

Весь набор →
modular-design-principles Скилл modular-design-principles даёт правила модульной архитектуры и изолированных контекстов без привязки к стеку. Помогает спроектировать границы модулей и найти неявную связность. CX Codex +1 ★ 7 191звёзд репо react-native-expert Скилл react-native-expert для Claude ведёт мобильный проект как старший инженер: компоненты React Native, навигация Expo Router, списки и анимации без просадок. CX Codex +1 ★ 7 191звёзд репо component-identification-sizing Скилл component-identification-sizing строит карту компонентов кодовой базы, считает их размер и показывает, что стоит разделить первым. CX Codex +1 ★ 7 191звёзд репо skill-architect Скилл skill-architect для Claude Code ведёт от идеи до готового SKILL.md: уточняет задачу, выбирает паттерн и структуру папки, проверяет описание. Помогает агенту повторять процесс одинаково. CX Codex +1 ★ 7 191звёзд репо excalidraw-studio Скилл excalidraw-studio для Claude Code создаёт файлы .excalidraw по текстовому описанию. Создаёт блок-схемы, архитектурные схемы, mind map и ER-диаграммы. CX Codex +1 ★ 7 191звёзд репо not-your-babysitter Скилл not-your-babysitter переводит агента в режим старшего оператора: доводит задачу до проверенного результата и почти не дёргает вас вопросами. CX Codex +1 ★ 7 191звёзд репо ai-pricing Скилл ai-pricing по стратегии цен для ИИ-продуктов: помогает выбрать, за что брать деньги, собрать тарифы и посчитать маржу до того, как прайс уйдёт клиентам. CX Codex +1 ★ 7 191звёзд репо evolutionary-modular-architecture Скилл evolutionary-modular-architecture помогает спроектировать бэкенд как модульный монолит: границы по DDD, папки по агрегатам, ACL вокруг внешних систем и устойчивые вызовы. CX Codex +1 ★ 7 191звёзд репо

Спонсоры проекта

Компании, которые помогают держать аналитику открытой